Wedding Wednesday: Diamonds are a Hoax??? Rally, Dahling!

Photo Courtesy of

Photo Courtesy of

Monday night I was at Wild Wing Cafe with Tim and he had to help his coworker set up.  I took to Facebook on my phone and one of my FB buddies shared a most compelling post: Why Diamonds are a Sham.  You can read the entire article by clicking on the link but it really had some great points in it.  Mainly when a couple is starting out their lives together, why in the world should the guy be obligated to shell out $2000+ for a craptastic (excuse my French and fun fact, my auto correct tried to change craptastic to capitalistic. Coincidence? I think not), not even that rare rock.  And I think I just lost half of my subscribers but bear with me.

I have never really wanted a diamond ring. No really, I haven’t.  The only diamond I value belonged to my Nana.  It’s teeny by today’s standards but my love for it has nothing to do with the cut or the clarity.  It’s because it belonged to her.  And this is what I just don’t get.  It’s a lot to ask of a guy, the man that you love, to buy you something so useless to signify his self worth and love for you when he could really be putting that money towards a house for you to grow into, your retirement funds for when the two get old , even your honeymoon is a tad bit more practical (not by much but those are memories for the two of you).  It’s just not fair!  Poor men, and this is probably one of the few times I will ever take pity on the opposite sex, have it hard when it comes to proposing.  Just think of the unbelievable pressure of picking out the perfect ring for their budget, presenting it to the girl of their dreams, and then possibly getting shot down because the rock wasn’t big enough.  Obviously he doesn’t love you girl; he can’t even bring himself to buy you a full carat.  Dump him!   Of course, this is a crazy dramatization but most people have been brainwashed to believe the bigger the diamond, the more he loves you.  You know who did the brainwashing?  In the article, the writer alludes to the company that stands to make the most profit from the brainwashing: jewelry stores.  It’s no secret they mark up their stuff 100-200%.  You can read more about it in the article but believe it or not, there was a time when people had some sense and thought diamond engagement rings were impractical.  Not many people cared to buy them.  So the jewelry stores came up with an ingenious marketing strategy: diamonds are forever. And they got celebrity endorsement.  The next thing you know, EVERYONE HAS TO HAVE A DIAMOND!  And this trend has stuck.  I can’t go a day without hearing yet another commercial about finding that perfect ring to “show her how much  you care.”  Really?  Show me you care by giving me a hug, making me dinner, letting me watch my favorite movie, and then making me coffee the next morning. Be the awesome man you need to be and you will never have to show you care with an overpriced stone.

Let me take a step back really quick before I lose my entire readership.  Girls, I know the pressure for you is high too.  Whenever you get engaged, the first thing friends and family ask for is the ring.  Right?  “Ooooo, show me the ring.”  You have big shoes to fill from generations of brainwashing.  You want to impress your friends and family with how awesome your guy is by showing the ring off a little.  I get it.  Part of me relishes the thought, as well.  It’s our time in the spotlight.  However, if you set up the expectation you will receive a diamond upon engagement and the money just isn’t there you will have to settle for something less extravagant than what you hoped for.  And then your friends might pull the “you don’t want a big ring anyway” bit.  But deep down you have a feeling they are unimpressed and think your new fiance is a cheapskate.  But it’s not your fault if you want or have a diamond ring already.


Tough question to answer, right?  Even with me not REALLY wanting a diamond there is a part of me who dreams about that stupid robin’s egg blue Tiffany box.  And it’s because I was taught that a diamond ring was the epitome of romance and class.  It meant that I had made it as a woman in the world, found the love of my life, and was going to ride off in the sunset.

Image Courtesy of

Image Courtesy of

I even was going to compromise with my girly whims by hunting down a gorgeous moissanite imitation diamond ring (which part of me still desperately wants). Compared to a diamond ring, it was about $2000 less expensive.  But the ring itself was still a little pricy.  I don’t ever want to have to ask my future husband to buy me a still overly expensive piece of jewelry to seal the deal.  What I really want is just to be asked.  A sincere, I love you; marry me.  Then he can take the money that he didn’t spend on the ring and put it towards our future together.  Rings get lost, time ages them, but true love doesn’t need a token to be validated.

Do you agree or disagree?  Keep the comments polite.  No bickering.


5 thoughts on “Wedding Wednesday: Diamonds are a Hoax??? Rally, Dahling!

  1. I’ve never really cared about diamonds, either, not for noble reasons, but simply because I’m not one for jewelry. I don’t even have my ears pierced. So I had no thoughts about what kind of ring I’d like. When Jason asked me to marry him, his parents gave him the ring that his dad used to propose to his mom. While the ring does have a diamond, it means more to me than him running out and buying a diamond ring because it represents many things: a sense of tradition, a warming welcome to their family and an understanding that material things are not the basis of our affection.

  2. Loved this! I feel the same way about diamonds. I am, however, interested in these lab created stones, particularly sapphire. They have just as much “fire” as the real stone and look gorgeous! The best part is they are a fraction of the average stone price! I am not big on rings or necklaces, but Carat has some pretty classy stuff! I regret not buying anything when they had a shop in New York, NY back in 2008. They do have an online store though, check it out!

I Need Comments to Live! Tell Me What You Think...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s